Special case 1: Sentences with a form of "be" as predicate
She is a girl with a red cap.
We want to ask for a girl with a red cap. The problem is the predicate. To be grammatically correct, we must admit that the
predicate is is a girl with a red cap. However, we are only interested in verb forms here and so is is everything we have.
Before you get a stupid idea like "Let's cut 'is' in two!" I tell you what to do:
Forget complicated rules. Really.
Whenever a form of 'be' is the only
verb form in a sentence, you just go the German way and put it in front of the subject.
In our example, Who is she? is the correct question. (For the less polite people: Yes, What is she? is also grammatically correct.)
Here are some examples:
He is a hungry wolf.
|Is he a hungry wolf?
Her house is in the wood.
|Where is her house?
This is so easy to understand.
|Why is this so easy to understand?
(Jump back to the Questions main page)